skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Great service, awesome takeout, fresh and hot!
Mark Miller via google.com - May 22, 2020
Stay away from the crab dip. It's dreadful. Warm mayo, crab and no seasonings. They should Google and find a good recipe.
J Rodgers via google.com - May 18, 2020
Great place for good food, good music and family owned.
Michael Sneeringer via google.com - Apr 8, 2020
Good lunch. Seemed to be short staffed during our visit. Typically I would go with seafood, but they had a very good beef and portabella mushroom wrap.
Michael LeGay via google.com - Mar 17, 2020
Excellent! Good food served quick. We bought a pint of Bleu cheese dressing to go. If you are ever bbn in Gettysburg, this is worth the trip!
Jay Wellington via google.com - Mar 9, 2020
Our server was Jessica she was great !!
Our server was Jessica she was great !!
Melissa Dewees Angleberger via facebook.com - Mar 8, 2020
Good food and service
We had a very enjoyable meal and service at Bay City. The crab cakes were excellent and the soup was steaming hot when it was brought out. Would definitely go back again.
hochey15 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 8, 2020
We've been coming here for 20+ years for sea food . Hanovers best spot for steaks and sea food ... read more
Pigeon FanCam via google.com - Mar 7, 2020
AYCE crab leg deal very good. Best home made dressings around. I buy quarts to bring home.Ranch and blue cheese family favorites ... read more
Michele Lane via google.com - Mar 2, 2020
Great food and service, good portions for the prices, and a nice casual atmosphere.
drbdriley via google.com - Feb 23, 2020
Very good seafood I love it it's a little pricey but it's worth it ... read more
Jeff Kope via google.com - Feb 21, 2020
Bay City has long been the upscale seafood restaurant in the area. Casual bar or fine dining seating. Food always satisfies.
David Bolton via google.com - Feb 21, 2020
Never had a bad meal there.Always great service too.Crab imperial is awesome ... read more
Buck Mehring via google.com - Feb 16, 2020
An excellent restaurant! The fried oysters are amazing!
John Peters via google.com - Feb 16, 2020
Delicious ... read more
molly hayes via google.com - Feb 15, 2020
Great Valentine's day meal. Seafood prepared to perfection. Shout out to Mathew our waiter. "Grea
Great Valentine's day meal. Seafood prepared to perfection. Shout out to Mathew our waiter. "Great job" ... read more
Gordon P. Burgett Jr. via facebook.com - Feb 15, 2020
Place is nice. Good was very good ... read more
Dave Weyant via google.com - Feb 15, 2020
The service was good, the food was awesome!
Sharon Weyant via google.com - Feb 14, 2020
love there crab cakes ,really good food.
love there crab cakes ,really good food.
Tammy Curry via facebook.com - Feb 14, 2020
awesome food crab legs, salmon Montey Carlo and our grandson had shrimp. two alcoholic beverages an
awesome food crab legs, salmon Montey Carlo and our grandson had shrimp. two alcoholic beverages and a soda. 74.00 for virtually the same meal at ted Lobster was 25 dollars more without the kids meals and quality wasn't close. highly recommend them. will definitely be back.
Clay Durham via facebook.com - Feb 9, 2020
Great food, service and the prices are not bad!
Jacob Smith via google.com - Feb 8, 2020
We visited Bay City for a birthday party. I thoroughly enjoyed the crab cake sandwich. The banquet hall was very nice. It wasn't my first time there. I really like going to Bay City for their oyster stew. It's the best.
Mike via google.com - Feb 1, 2020
Food was very good except for the Calamari. It was chewy.
Joanne Schmuck via google.com - Jan 26, 2020
A couple weeks ago was the first I’ve ever eaten at Bay City. My fiancé had eaten there several times, and suggested we go there for lunch. We were greeted nicely by the hostess and our server. We each got a cup of soup and split an appetizer as large as an entree. The portions were so large we couldn’t finish our meal. But, everythi ... read more
Danny Goss via google.com - Jan 24, 2020
The food was very good and not too pricey. Large portions, as well.
Paul Ries via google.com - Jan 24, 2020
Great food, great ambiance...always a pleasant experience with that special someone or just hanging out with family and friends. I highly recommend :-) ... read more
Eric our song Perez via google.com - Jan 22, 2020
The staff was friendly. Food is just okay. Oyster sandwich was sad. It was only two oysters smashed and set between two slices of sandwich bread.
Lora Davis via google.com - Jan 20, 2020
Amazing food ... read more
molly musselman via google.com - Jan 16, 2020
Really nice place for date night or family night out. Great food and super friendly waitresses.
Wanda Reynolds via google.com - Jan 12, 2020
Great food and service.
ronald kramer via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Great food and our waitress, Missy, was great!
Barry Stine via google.com - Jan 5, 2020
First time eating there's food was very good and service was good ... read more
Eugene Roth via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
First time visit. Had heard about great food. Searching for a place to dine in November 2020 for a potential large group. Met by a hostess who was gracious and kind. My husband explained the needs in November. We were seated and after ordering we met several staff and he toured the different dining areas. Our waitress was sweet and a ... read more
Linda Floyd via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Nice atmosphere.
Audrey Gaines via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Delicious food. Quality is consistently good ... read more
Sheena Russell via google.com - Dec 27, 2019
Great service ... read more
Juwan Harris via google.com - Dec 27, 2019
Food is fine. Quick service. They need to update the benches and tables. Meals are averaged priced but to sit in a bench with all the tears , snagged my dress on Christmas eve. Time to update!!!
Linette Duvall via google.com - Dec 25, 2019
Great food great service ... read more
Kellie Smith via google.com - Dec 25, 2019
all you can eat snow crabs ftw ... read more
Scott Davis via google.com - Dec 22, 2019
Not A Bad Choice in Hanover
We decided to give Bay City a try having driven past it for years. iI's a spacious nautically decorated restaurant, although it's getting a bit long in the tooth. We had no complaints about the service. The seafood was fine -- nothing spectacular but not...More ... read more
48NYSV via tripadvisor.com - Dec 21, 2019
Great food and friendly staff!
Geffie Baker via google.com - Dec 21, 2019
We have been to Bay City Restaurant ...
We have been to Bay City Restaurant several times as it is very close to our house. The times we have gone for seafood (it is a seafood restaurant) we were disappointed. Maybe it's because we were born and bred in Maryland and know the great seafood restaurants there. I almost always go for the crab cake and that is definitely a 2 st ... read more
Daryll B. via yelp.com - Dec 18, 2019
They r great we have been going there for ambers banquets for work since she started at the hart center ... read more
Rebecka Speelman via google.com - Dec 18, 2019
Exxxpencive ... read more
Robert Harrod via google.com - Dec 17, 2019
Great food. Private event was nice and waitress was fantastic.
dietrichmotorsports via google.com - Dec 15, 2019
Company Christmas party... Food and service was amazing!
Amanda Becker via google.com - Dec 15, 2019
Good food good service ... read more
David Utermahlen via google.com - Dec 15, 2019
Love the staff Traci is amazing and well organized. The food is always amazing . Thank you ... read more
Diana Tabak via google.com - Dec 13, 2019
Food was okay. Nice atmosphere. Waitress friendly. They did get my drink wrong. We had a nice view looking straight back into the kitchen and saw a man with a cast on with no gloves on either hand preparing food.
Jessica Speelman via google.com - Dec 1, 2019
Had lunch there today -- great ...
Had lunch there today -- great crab cake!  Sat at the bar and the service was excellent!
Craig R. via yelp.com - Nov 27, 2019
Service good. Long wait for food ... read more
Kasie Altland via google.com - Nov 27, 2019
Excellent meal
We all enjoyed our dinner once again at Bay City. The food was hot and fresh. We ordered a variety of dishes from the extensive menu - seafood, chicken, steak, soup, desserts. Everything was delicious. The service was great - very attentive to our needs....More ... read more
Travmama via tripadvisor.com - Nov 23, 2019
The seafood combination meal has always been our favorite.
The seafood combination meal has always been our favorite.
Trudy McDonald Sprecher via facebook.com - Nov 16, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor