skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Anniversary dinner 27th
Tonight was great, food, service and outdoor dining. I did pick 2, crab cake and salmon. Both very good. Nice craft beer selection. Been here before but food seemed very top notch tonight. Fresh seafood a must try ... read more
stevesR4812KI via tripadvisor.com - Oct 10, 2020
Staff were pleasant, attentive and friendly. Quality of food unimpressive and somewhat pricey. Appetizers and dessert were best part of the experience. This restaurant has been hit or miss. For a Friday night, I would've expected their "A" game. Maybe next time.
Laura Bowman via google.com - Oct 3, 2020
Food was good. Service was great. However, it is way overpriced for what you get.
Tiffany Wivell via google.com - Oct 1, 2020
Enjoyed a wonderful gathering with friends. Food was delicious. Delicious crab dip for appetizer and the Maryland crab soup spicy and best around! Thanks for being open during these COVID times so we can still safely enjoy life a bit!
Susan Wierman via google.com - Sep 29, 2020
Loved the seafood nachos!!!!
Vickie Stansbury via google.com - Sep 20, 2020
I WOULD LOVE TO THANK BAY CITY SEAFOOD RESTAURANT FOR OUR EXPERIENCE YESTERDAY AFTER HAVING A NOT SO GOOD MOMENT AT ANOTHER SO CALLED ESTABLISHMENT ...I SAY MOMENT DUE TO NOT GIVING THEM THE PLEASURE TO TREAT US THE WAY THEY DID...WE ALL WALKED OUT DUE TO HER ATTITUDE AND THE FEELING THAT WE INCONVENCED HER.....LUCKILY BAY CITY WAS O ... read more
Chato Dejesus via google.com - Sep 8, 2020
Great food and service. Had outside dining and it was a nice experience.
Aggie Myer via google.com - Sep 7, 2020
Worth it for the crab soup alone.great salad as well. Can't wait to come back for dinner. Deck dining as well.
Khal NEPA via google.com - Sep 5, 2020
Good service and clean. Soup a bit cold. All else good ... read more
Luann Gebhart via google.com - Sep 4, 2020
The food was great, the service wonderful. Eating on the patio was a real treat.
Willa Lau via google.com - Sep 2, 2020
Good food ... read more
Donna Bosserman via google.com - Aug 26, 2020
Great seafood ... read more
Fayanna Parker via google.com - Aug 24, 2020
Love their crab legs!
Karen m. Welter via google.com - Aug 23, 2020
This place is great. Wonderful atmosphere and our waitress Teresa was great!!!Will b back again.😊😊😊 ... read more
Kathy Schweiger via google.com - Aug 23, 2020
A great place to work.
Michael Woodward via google.com - Aug 21, 2020
I live in Virginia now but lived in Hanover PA all my life. Bay City is my favorite seafood restaur
I live in Virginia now but lived in Hanover PA all my life. Bay City is my favorite seafood restaurant. They are wonderful people and the food is so yummy.
Josie Albin via facebook.com - Aug 12, 2020
Very good place to eat! Wonderful food, great service and very affordable.
crystal hutchens via google.com - Aug 8, 2020
LOVE..LOVE..LOVE.. Bay City Seafood Restaurant...the food is ALWAYS good and the service is Fabulous..
Numbers Lady via google.com - Aug 8, 2020
Great food. Good customer service ... read more
Charles B via google.com - Aug 5, 2020
Glad to see them back after Covid shutdown. Great food and service. Love eating on the deck and the shrimp salad is my favorite. Also great crab cakes.
Patricia Miller via google.com - Aug 2, 2020
Really good wings.
Michael Livelsberger via google.com - Jul 30, 2020
I like this place the food was great but ,we arrive the waitress that was waiting on people never acknowledge us we sat their for an half an hour .I finally got up and ask the Lady inside .She came an taken care of us .I want to thank her. .
Elaine Luckenbaugh via google.com - Jul 29, 2020
Great "Maryland Style Crab Cakes" our Favorite "Above the Masion Dixon line" Seafood Destination; Seafood Market and Carryout available as well!
David Basler via google.com - Jul 24, 2020
Always great. The staff makes the place!
Jacque Machlinski via google.com - Jul 23, 2020
It was ok. Seafood Fast Food more or less. But certain items are worth it. It's not Bo Brooks but it will do for Hanover.
Alex Martin via google.com - Jul 14, 2020
great meal. good service and quick
great meal. good service and quick ... read more
Ken Sunday via facebook.com - Jul 8, 2020
The coconut shrimp are amazing. Service is friendly and the atmosphere is welcoming. A nice spot to relax and enjoy a good drink with good friends.
Robert Ireland via google.com - Jul 7, 2020
Ordered an entre salad with chicken. Came in a relatively small bowl like a side salad would come in. It was good. Also most of staff wore their masks just over their mouths not their nose as well. Made me feel uncomfortable. Covid 19 is real.
Orville McBeth via google.com - Jul 5, 2020
Great crabs Geat service
Great crabs Geat service ... read more
Jay Krumrine via facebook.com - Jul 4, 2020
Pretty good seafood if your in the area. The crab cake imperial is a must try. The cream of crab is good as well, lots of crab meat and thick.
Kristin Frauenhoffer via google.com - Jul 2, 2020
Nice return
We went here for our son’s birthday as he wanted seafood and it was our first time out in seated restaurant since the shutdown ended. We ate out on the deck and everyone got the pick-2 dinner option. Our waiter was on top of everything...More ... read more
cornmanrichards via tripadvisor.com - Jun 27, 2020
The service, appetizers, food, drinks & desserts were GREAT TODAY!! πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ˜‹πŸ˜‹β€β€
The service, appetizers, food, drinks & desserts were GREAT TODAY!! πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ˜‹πŸ˜‹β€β€ ... read more
Colleen Hassett Garrett via facebook.com - Jun 23, 2020
Absolutely perfect hard shells and snow crabs. What a father's day treat and the market pricing was a great deal..100% will be using them from now on for all our seafood needs!!
Josh Shaffer via google.com - Jun 23, 2020
Great food, great service and great atmosphere! Really enjoyed dinner and music on the deck. The bacon wrapped bbq shrimp app was the perfect start. And the Caribbean Sun cocktail sets the mood 🍹 ... read more
Erin Clare via google.com - Jun 21, 2020
Always friendly. Food was good and hot. Not my favorite place for dinner rolls. But everything else πŸ‘ ... read more
Vikki Rohrbaugh via google.com - Jun 20, 2020
The food is very good, it's a good place to dine at.
Walter Meck via google.com - Jun 18, 2020
Good Food , finally a restaurant open AND following the needed guidelines for public safety against the virus ... read more
Rich Gerner via google.com - Jun 17, 2020
Great people! Great food!
Great people! Great food!
MaryBeth Walls via facebook.com - Jun 14, 2020
Great local place with a nice menu. Friendly staff and good service.
Great local place with a nice menu. Friendly staff and good service.
Gary L. Baumgardner via facebook.com - Jun 12, 2020
Love this place! Outside was very nice today
Love this place! Outside was very nice today ... read more
Angie Neiderer-Staub via facebook.com - Jun 11, 2020
Food and service was very good. Looking to go back again.
Malcolm Smith via google.com - Jun 8, 2020
Take out order, entrees were great, salad was fresh. Only issue was a missing dessert (cheesecake) but the food was great.
Backpack via google.com - Jun 8, 2020
family owned and operated with delicious food and wide variety.
family owned and operated with delicious food and wide variety.
Scott Hughes via facebook.com - Jun 6, 2020
Great service, awesome takeout, fresh and hot!
Mark Miller via google.com - May 22, 2020
Stay away from the crab dip. It's dreadful. Warm mayo, crab and no seasonings. They should Google and find a good recipe.
J Rodgers via google.com - May 18, 2020
Great place for good food, good music and family owned.
Michael Sneeringer via google.com - Apr 8, 2020
Good lunch. Seemed to be short staffed during our visit. Typically I would go with seafood, but they had a very good beef and portabella mushroom wrap.
Michael LeGay via google.com - Mar 17, 2020
Excellent! Good food served quick. We bought a pint of Bleu cheese dressing to go. If you are ever bbn in Gettysburg, this is worth the trip!
Jay Wellington via google.com - Mar 9, 2020
Our server was Jessica she was great !!
Our server was Jessica she was great !!
Melissa Dewees Angleberger via facebook.com - Mar 8, 2020
Good food and service
We had a very enjoyable meal and service at Bay City. The crab cakes were excellent and the soup was steaming hot when it was brought out. Would definitely go back again.
hochey15 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 8, 2020
We've been coming here for 20+ years for sea food . Hanovers best spot for steaks and sea food ... read more
Pigeon FanCam via google.com - Mar 7, 2020
AYCE crab leg deal very good. Best home made dressings around. I buy quarts to bring home.Ranch and blue cheese family favorites ... read more
Michele Lane via google.com - Mar 2, 2020
Great food and service, good portions for the prices, and a nice casual atmosphere.
drbdriley via google.com - Feb 23, 2020
Very good seafood I love it it's a little pricey but it's worth it ... read more
Jeff Kope via google.com - Feb 21, 2020
Bay City has long been the upscale seafood restaurant in the area. Casual bar or fine dining seating. Food always satisfies.
David Bolton via google.com - Feb 21, 2020
Never had a bad meal there.Always great service too.Crab imperial is awesome ... read more
Buck Mehring via google.com - Feb 16, 2020
An excellent restaurant! The fried oysters are amazing!
John Peters via google.com - Feb 16, 2020
Delicious ... read more
molly hayes via google.com - Feb 15, 2020
Great Valentine's day meal. Seafood prepared to perfection. Shout out to Mathew our waiter. "Grea
Great Valentine's day meal. Seafood prepared to perfection. Shout out to Mathew our waiter. "Great job" ... read more
Gordon P. Burgett Jr. via facebook.com - Feb 15, 2020
Place is nice. Good was very good ... read more
Dave Weyant via google.com - Feb 15, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire